The early success of Bo Nix and Jayden Daniels in the NFL underscores a vital truth: pairing a rookie quarterback with the right coaching staff is crucial for long-term development. Both Nix and Daniels have flourished due to strong organizational support and the presence of experienced offensive minds. The Chicago Bears, however, have failed to replicate this formula for Caleb Williams, their promising No. 1 overall pick, and the results are starting to show.
Nix and Daniels: The Importance of Coaching
Nix and Daniels have set the league on fire in their rookie campaigns, thanks in no small part to the coaching they’ve received. Nix, under the tutelage of head coach Sean Payton and offensive coordinator Joe Lombardi in Denver, has shown incredible poise, completing nearly 66% of his passes for 2,275 yards, 14 touchdowns, and only six interceptions through 11 weeks while adding 295 rushing and another four trips to the end zone. Oh, let’s not forget, Nix even caught a touchdown earlier this year to bring his total number to 19 touchdowns through the first 11 weeks.
Lombardi, who helped mold Justin Herbert into one of the league’s top quarterbacks, has created a system emphasizing Nix’s strengths: quick decision-making and mobility.
Similarly, Jayden Daniels has flourished in Washington, where head coach Dan Quinn and offensive coordinator Kliff Kingsbury have constructed a quarterback-friendly offense. Daniels has passed for 2,338 yards, rushed for another 482, and accounted for 14 total touchdowns (10 passing, four rushing) while maintaining a passer rating just below 100 at 99.6. Kingsbury’s reputation as a quarterback guru has been instrumental in Daniels’ seamless transition to the NFL, creating an offense tailored to his dual-threat abilities.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
The Bears’ Coaching Woes
By contrast, the Chicago Bears have left Caleb Williams in a precarious situation. Head coach Matt Eberflus has failed to deliver, not just in terms of game preparation but also in fostering a culture conducive to a rookie quarterback’s development. Eberflus’ abysmal record in one-score games (5-17 since 2022) highlights his inability to manage tight situations, often leaving Williams exposed to unnecessary pressure.
The hiring of Shane Waldron as offensive coordinator compounded the Bears’ problems. Waldron, brought in for his experience with the Seattle Seahawks, was unable to adjust his play-calling to fit Williams’ skill set, ultimately leading to his dismissal. While Waldron’s firing was positioned as a solution, it was more of a scapegoat move to mask Eberflus’ larger failings.
A Glimpse of Hope
Following Waldron’s departure, interim offensive coordinator Thomas Brown simplified the Bears’ offense, focusing on quick reads and exploiting what the defense offered. This adjustment was evident in yesterday’s loss against the Green Bay Packers. Williams displayed marked improvement, releasing the ball faster, making decisive runs, and delivering clutch throws. It was a glimpse of what Williams can achieve with the proper guidance.
Despite the loss, it’s clear that Williams’ development remains at risk under the current regime. The Bears’ front office must prioritize hiring a head coach and offensive coordinator who can nurture their star quarterback. Caleb’s represents the future of the franchise, and his progression is non-negotiable.
Lessons for the Bears
The successes of Nix and Daniels provide a roadmap for the Bears:
1. Hire the Right Head Coach: An experienced, adaptable leader like Sean Payton or Dan Quinn can set the tone for a rookie quarterback’s career.
2. Prioritize Offensive Expertise: Bringing in a proven offensive coordinator, such as a Kliff Kingsbury or Joe Lombardi type, is essential.
3. Build Around the QB: Solidify the offensive line, create a balanced playbook, and maintain a strong running game to take pressure off the quarterback.
Looking Ahead
The Bears are likely to clean house at the end of the season, with Eberflus almost certainly on his way out. The next coaching staff must be chosen with Caleb Williams’ development as the central focus. The potential for greatness is there, but it requires the right environment to flourish.
As the Bears evaluate their options, one thing is clear: the margin for error is slim. Surrounding Williams with the right coaching talent isn’t just important—it’s critical for ensuring that he doesn’t become another example of wasted potential.
As Jack said, we need to stop putting these rookies on a pedestal. Remember Carson Wentz? RG3? Even Love and Stroud have come back to earth this season. Has Caleb been “worse” than Daniels, Nix, and even Maye? Yes. He also has the worse situation as far as coaching goes. Daniels’ head coach has been to a Super Bowl while he coached Matt Ryan, and now has a quality offensive mind that shaped the offense into what Daniels did well. That’s great coaching! The league is starting to figure it out, and Daniels has struggled since the Bears game. Nix… Read more »
@Slip Knotz – thank you for the compliment, although I suspect a (large) number of people here will tell you I know nothing. Which is OK, too. I agree on your list of needs. But Poles tried to get a 3tech once, then never really tried again. We do disagree on Eberflus. Most of what I know comes from reading different analysts and sites, which I usually prefer to be outside of the Bears media market. And most of what I read aligns with the eye test for me on Eberflus. He is a solid top – 12 or thereabouts… Read more »
@Tred I disagree with your view. I appreciate your opinion and I enjoy reading your posts. You obviously know a lot about football. But in this case we don’t agree. My current assessment is this: We have a rookie QB that can’t connect deep. We have Rome getting open a few times per game and Caleb cannot take advantage. We have a rookie QB who cannot beat the blitz so they keep blitzing because it works. We have maybe an improving run game. My #1 complaint has been that Waldron seemed to abandon the run game so I’m seeing this… Read more »
Well, some of us liked Nix coming into the draft, while some others liked Daniels. The reasoning behind people liking those other QBs was usually at least partially based on the feeling that this team needed the additional draft picks that could be had by trading down in order to try and build our OL, and to a lesser extent our DL. But the less important truth is that as soon as it was clear that King Poles was taking Williams, 75% of the people here jumped on the Williams train. I think that happened because they were misled by… Read more »
I think we need a little more honesty amongst fans here. Some of us wanted to trade down for a “good” QB vs a “Hyped” QB so that we could get some linemen, The Packers have had one of the best O-Lines since 2018 and the Bears can’t beat them. Bears don’t even have a complete D-Line. The GM is supposedly a Line guru but the Bears always have weak line-play on both sides of the ball, save Sweat who wasn’t drafted. So we have a bunch of angry fans that a rookie Qb and rookie WR haven’t produced. Well… Read more »