The Chicago Bears put in a request last week to speak with Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy, who had an expiring contract. They were denied by Dallas, who seemed hopeful they could still work out an agreement to extend him. A few days later, talks had gone nowhere. McCarthy officially became a free agent on January 14th. Just 24 hours later, the Bears are meeting with him in person. Such a rapid turnaround, along with the reported first-class treatment he’s receiving, leads many to wonder if he’s the favorite for the job.
It is hard not to feel like this is a deliberate effort by the organization to woo somebody they covet. McCarthy does check a lot of the boxes GM Ryan Poles and team president Kevin Warren desire. Poles wants an offensive-minded coach who can develop quarterback Caleb Williams. Warren prefers somebody with previous head coaching experience. McCarthy has coached for 18 seasons between Green Bay and Dallas, posting a winning record in 12 of them. He developed Aaron Rodgers and maximized Dak Prescott. The Bears have good reasons to be serious about him, and according to Jeff Hughes of Da Bears Blog, they very much are.
Mike McCarthy is a perfectly sensible option for the Bears.
Fans don’t like it because his presence interferes with the prospect of landing Ben Johnson, the hottest name on the circuit. Many see him as the next Sean McVay or Kyle Shanahan. That might be true, but it’s important to remember that luring coaches to your team isn’t guaranteed. Others are vying for his services too. Even if the Bears make the best pitch possible, Johnson could end up going elsewhere. It would be a mistake to throw all of their efforts into landing him and not have contingency plans in place.
There is no question Mike McCarthy is a solid one. For all the criticism he gets for not achieving enough during his runs in Green Bay and Dallas, the fact is his track record is almost identical to Sean Payton, who many see as a future Hall of Famer. Both have a Super Bowl ring. Both have over 170 wins in their careers. If people believe Payton can win another championship in Denver, why is it crazy to believe McCarthy can’t in Chicago? It may not be a sexy idea, but it’s also not a bad one.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
@Rocketrider: Yes, I can hear the parody song in my head, “M-m-m-Mikey and the Jets” (to the tune of Benny and the Jets, by Sir Elton John.) The bad result, for the Bears, would be that the Saints decide Johnson and Glenn aren’t reasonable for them to get, so they make an offer to McCarthy, and won’t wait three weeks for the Lions’ season to end, so McCarthy takes it, then Ben goes to the Raiders, and for good measure, the Cowboys sign Monken, so the Bears are left with their pick of the rest. Glenn to the Jets seems… Read more »
Hey “BIG Mike” — bring Will McClay with you to Halas Hall.
I understand that he’s great on the “putt-putt carpet.”
McCarthy couldn’t win in Dallas with an owner that overpays for anything to win but yet they haven’t won hardly anything except regular season games. Playoff wise they suck. And @Dr M. ….McCarthy and the jets…that would be so funny..
If Mike McCarthy is the hire, Kevin Warren runs things. If Ben Johnson is the hire, then Ryan Poles runs things. We will all find out soon enough.
That’s probably why they have struggled in the playoffs. He is 11-11 in the playoffs. To counter a poor rushing attack, he usually has a top 5 offense, though. Not a bad consolation prize.