Thursday Night Football was rough for Caleb Williams. He endured another seven sacks in a 6-3 loss to the Seattle Seahawks, bringing his total to 67 for the season. However, the moment that seems to have gained some attention over the past few days came during the broadcast. At one point, color commentator Kirk Herbstreit openly questioned Williams’ preparation and leadership as a quarterback. It was a bizarre moment that he quickly tried to move away from, but many have called him out for it.
“I think the thing that remains to be seen — and only time will tell — is if he understands what it takes to be an NFL quarterback as far as the preparation, as far as first guy there, last guy to leave.”
One person took special umbrage with the comments.
Doug Farrar of Athlon Sports suggested that Herbstreit wouldn’t have said something like that if he were white. Yet because Williams is black, the analyst questioned his intelligence, which is something racially motivated people have said for decades.
“It may not seem like a big deal until you dive into the ways in which Black athletes have been portrayed since they’ve been allowed to play sports. The NFL had a “gentlemen’s agreement” which banned any Black player from the game from 1934 to the mid-1940s, and even when a trickle of players were allowed to participate, it was usually not at the “positions of intelligence” – quarterback, center, middle linebacker, safety…
…So, when we talk about a Black rookie quarterback like Caleb Williams, it behooves us to remember to hold ourselves to the same standards that we would were we talking about white quarterbacks. Again, one paragraph of talk in an unexciting game doesn’t seem like a big deal – Herbstreit was probably trying to create a narrative on the fly to keep people tuned in – but when you look at the history, it’s much more than it seems.”
Caleb Williams deserves more respect.
This is another in a long line of pointless crap Williams has to deal with. He already has people calling him out for not being efficient enough because of his lower completion percentage and tendency to take unnecessary sacks. Never mind the fact he has broken several rookie passing records despite both his offensive coordinator and head coach getting fired in the middle of a season. What exactly is he supposed to do with such a chaotic situation around him? There is no pleasing some people.
Is Herbstreit racist? Unlikely. Still, that doesn’t make his comments any less dumb, insensitive, and backward. There have been indications for years that Caleb Williams has a stellar work ethic and leadership qualities. Surviving this season with a positive passing stat line would’ve been impossible otherwise. There is a fine line between fair critique and useless criticism.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
If nothing else, this is another reason for Bears fans to rally around their quarterback. Williams is putting his body on the line to help this team win and getting hate for it. Time to show him the city has his back.
My God, over half of the league is black. What, only white players can be characterized as being unprepared?? This moron Farrar thinks that preparedness is somehow equivalent to intelligence. That says all I need to know about this nimrod Farrar.
This article has to be a joke, or on the other hand it has to be the biggest display of hypocrisy ever put into writing, lets start with the fake racist comment about Caleb, c’mon man really…? Then if you just go back to a few months ago, this writer tarred and feathered Justin Field as the dumbest and most ineffective QB in the history of the Bears, the writer literally showed hatred for almost anything Justin Fields, now he wants to make a fake racist story about Caleb and tell us to rally around Caleb, man get a life… Read more »
I sense there are both semantical confusion and the loss of historical context for some here.
Talkin’ Frank Gifford on MNF too–what a hypocrite and con artist on morality and racism.
Doug Farrar, nor our boy here Eric, did their research. Now, I am 100% certain of the actual source of the comment, and it wasn’t Herbstreit. He was just reporting on what Bears coach Chris Beatty said when he was asked about Caleb’s development in year 1. It was one part of a much longer answer about all of the things people don’t realize a rookie QB needs to learn, it was said last week at Halas Hall in response to reporter questions (outside of the regular press briefing from the podium) and the audio was played by Mark Grote,… Read more »
Labeling people is illiberal and neo-fascist unless it is correct.