Former NFL quarterback Kurt Benkert recently broke down Caleb Williams’ performance, providing an insightful assessment of the Chicago Bears rookie. According to Benkert, Williams shows flashes of brilliance reminiscent of Patrick Mahomes but has areas to refine before reaching that elite level.
Benkert highlighted Williams’ ability to deliver jaw-dropping plays while pointing out that his consistency in footwork and decision-making still needs development. Williams’ potential trajectory offers Bears fans hope that, with the right guidance and time, he could become one of the NFL’s premier quarterbacks.
Building Consistency
Benkert’s analysis emphasizes Williams’ inconsistent footwork, particularly in quick passing situations. While his mechanics can falter, resulting in missed opportunities on simpler throws, this is a fixable issue. For quarterbacks of his caliber, refinement often comes with experience and coaching. As Williams continues to adjust to the NFL’s speed, developing muscle memory for consistent footwork will be key to eliminating these “missed layups.”
The Spectacular Side
What sets Williams apart, according to Benkert, are the extraordinary plays he’s capable of making. Whether evading defenders, extending plays, or delivering pinpoint throws into tight windows, Williams mirrors Mahomes’ signature improvisational brilliance. In the Bears’ most recent game, his highlight moments demonstrated his rare ability to turn broken plays into spectacular results.
Subscribe to the BFR Youtube channel and ride shotgun with Dave and Ficky as they break down Bears football like nobody else.
These high-ceiling plays showcase Williams’ natural instincts and athleticism, qualities that make him a threat on every snap. Benkert praised Williams’ progression throughout the game, a promising sign for a young quarterback learning on the fly.
Decision-Making Growth
A critique that Benkert offered was Williams’ occasional tendency to try too hard to make big plays when safer, smarter options like a check-down were available. Mahomes faced similar challenges early in his career, particularly during his MVP season when he balanced his penchant for deep passes with greater reliance on short, efficient gains.
For Williams, mastering this “game within the game” will be crucial. Learning when to take risks and when to settle for incremental gains can elevate him from a highlight-reel quarterback to an all-around winner.
The Mahomes Comparison
Patrick Mahomes has become the gold standard for quarterbacks, blending creativity, intelligence, and execution. Like Williams, Mahomes entered the NFL as a raw talent with tremendous upside. Under the guidance of Andy Reid, he quickly refined his skills, unlocking a level of dominance that few could have predicted.
Benkert’s comparison of Williams to Mahomes isn’t hyperbolic—it’s a realistic projection of his ceiling if he addresses the finer aspects of his game. Williams’ ability to make plays outside the structure, coupled with his arm talent and mobility, draws natural parallels to Mahomes’ style.
Why the Bears Matter
To reach his full potential, Williams needs the right environment. Mahomes benefited from Reid’s quarterback-friendly system, while Williams faces the challenge of developing under a team still solidifying its coaching direction. Interim offensive coordinator Thomas Brown has already helped simplify the offense, which could aid Williams in developing the consistency and decision-making he needs.
The Future
Kurt Benkert’s analysis paints an encouraging picture of Caleb Williams’ future. While he isn’t Mahomes yet, the tools and traits are there. If the Bears commit to building around their young quarterback with strong coaching and a balanced system, the Mahomes comparison could become a reality. For now, Williams’ progression offers a glimpse of the greatness Chicago has been searching for at quarterback for decades.
@Bear_Down I said thank you already. Not sure what you want from me
There is NO TIME TO WASTE. Mahomes was an OT loss to Tom Brady’s Patriots away from reaching the SB in his first year as a starter. The Bears already wasted this year by not moving on from Eberflus in the offseason like Tom Waddle Told Ya to. The only positive of wasting this year is to give Caleb a little taste of adversity which will contribute to his growth. With the cap space and draft picks the Bears will have for 2025, the expectations must be to be legit contenders for the SB, even if they fall short along… Read more »
There is no singular path to excellence or greatness. So says I, Odin.
Consistently, week after week doing what he did the last two weeks is the next step. Kid is going to be great. I have zero doubts. But the difference between Mahomes and everyone not named Tom Brady is super bowls. That’s a long ways to go.
@Bears57 You don’t need to be privy to the inner workings but should be informed about what is being reported when it’s going down. A quick Google search will confirm the benching rumor. It was supposedly leaked to an ESPN reporter by Travis Bagent. Look up on Google or SM “Matt Eberflus Reportedly Tried to Weasel His Way Into Keeeping Waldron”. Ultimately he fired him but had to be told to do so. This was reported on the Rich Eisen Show by Tom Pelissero.